Originally posted by Nickgoh45:
Permission to use the faregates will be granted, however I'd be editing the faregates to make it more realistic, so don't use it yet till I've done the necessary modifications.
As for personal opinion on this project, I'd have to say that I wouldn't really support the idea of doing an express route like this, since basically what you're doing is repeating the section of route from JUR to CCK on NSL. As for the part from CCK to PYL, I don't quite understand how you're going to connect these two stations, since if you're going to build the route following the whole NSL, it won't make economical sense in real life, and if you're going to turn back at CCK, the curve can be quite sharp. I'd recommend you change your alphanumerical codes and order of the stations.
Probably it is cutting the central catchment or something like that, duplicating DTL Stage 2 / 3 with no stations without cutting in the Downtown (DTL Stage 1) portion before turning down in MacPherson towards Paya Lebar.
Personal opinion: Route not sensible. I rather u do a ficitional line on Tuas South towards Teban then a upward extension towards Jurong East (Middle track station?) and continue Eastwards via West Coast, Depot Road, Bukit Merah / Radin Mas, Keppel, and ends at New Downtown / Marina Barrage.
Seriously, like NickGoh said, Doing CCK to PYL will be a milestone. Who the heck is gonna drive around 50-100km (ESTIMATION!) Without a station? tll be too boring..
Edit: Like Samuel said. 30km-35km only.. Sorry.
Originally posted by Bngauw:Seriously, like NickGoh said, Doing CCK to PYL will be a milestone. Who the heck is gonna drive around 50-100km (ESTIMATION!) Without a station? tll be too boring..
It is not 50 - 100km dude! It is not like Singapore - KL.
CCK - Paya Lebar is more likely 30km ~ 35km. The straight line from Changi Point to Tuas West (Checkpoint) is like 42km ONLY
Lol.
Originally posted by C751A 70049/70050:It is not 50 - 100km dude! It is not like Singapore - KL.
CCK - Paya Lebar is more likely 30km ~ 35km. The straight line from Changi Point to Tuas West (Checkpoint) is like 42km ONLY
Well i never realised Singapore is so tiny... Thought one end to the other at least 50km (Around There lah.. Don't correct me..)
Even though I may not approve this route, but do include some stations between CCK and PYL? It will definitely get boring while travelling between the 2 stations.
Okay. I will add more stations.
@ joeyfjj
Can I use your mailbox ,GTM Machine and HHPSD.
Bolded are from the Habourvale city light rail line.
(Took away Kegstone platform because not suitable)
Can I use the platform from the nsl (xpo4.csv)
Originally posted by Boylush:Okay. I will add more stations.
@ joeyfjj
Can I use your mailbox ,GTM Machine and HHPSD and the Kegstone station platform.
Bolded are from the Habourvale city light rail line.
Maybe, you may try CCK go to BPJ and up to Woodlands directly, go Sembawang cut Mandai, Kebun Bharu, Thomson, Novena, Little India, Kallang Basin, Kallang Bharu then go Paya Lebar.
Originally posted by C751A 70049/70050:Maybe, you may try CCK go to BPJ and up to Woodlands directly, go Sembawang cut Mandai, Kebun Bharu, Thomson, Novena, Little India, Kallang Basin, Kallang Bharu then go Paya Lebar.
Great. More Stations! 12 More stations. Better than only 4 Stops. How boring will that be?
Originally posted by Boylush:Okay. I will add more stations.
@ joeyfjj
Can I use your mailbox ,GTM Machine and HHPSD.
Bolded are from the Habourvale city light rail line.
(Took away Kegstone platform because not suitable)
Can I use the platform from the nsl (xpo4.csv)
Mailbox and GTM are from an object library, meaning free to use.
HHPSD will be updated too, but take it if you need it.
okay.Sorry for not posting this few days due to my end of year exams.
I got permission from willis to use his xpo4.csv platform.
I have almost completed the station objects.
Can I change the line to Resort Island Line. There would be no change in the line except the naming. Plan to go from Coney Island , Lexington and to East Harbour.
To developers : Can I tender for that line?
Originally posted by Boylush:Can I change the line to Resort Island Line. There would be no change in the line except the naming. Plan to go from Coney Island , Lexington and to East Harbour.
To developers : Can I tender for that line?
From the station East Harbour, is this perhaps a change to Harbourvale?
The line go into the resort and the resort is in a island?
As I've posted in the History of openBVE HBV City MRT and LRT system thread, the line was supposed to be developed by me, and I personally do not approve of this project. I'm not shooting anybody here, neither am I trying to start a flame war here, therefore I'm politely posting here. If you don't like my opinion, we can work things out together. :)
Well. I supposed the topic is SCRAPPED. Unless Boylush decides to continue on the NSX. If not, this topic will probably be done forever. Until I bump it in November.
Originally posted by Bngauw:Well. I supposed the topic is SCRAPPED. Unless Boylush decides to continue on the NSX. If not, this topic will probably be done forever. Until I bump it in November.
Nah, he can just call it another route.
Originally posted by joeyfjj:Nah, he can just call it another route.
Thinking of another name is difficult. He should stay with NSX. Besides, he has to think of new stations and a route to that station if he changes the name..
Okay. Maybe I will rename the line to South West Line as it does not make sense if I use the below stations
South West Line will be operating at these stations mentioned below:
SW1 East Harbour
SW2 Coal Harbour
and the last station for now
SW3 Exhibition Centre.
All stations will be overground.
SW1 would be@ the third level due to the space constraints.
Thats all for now.
Can anyone give me any feedback on this line.
Will be doing the RATIS today.
Originally posted by Boylush:Okay. Maybe I will rename the line to South West Line as it does not make sense if I use the below stations
South West Line will be operating at these stations mentioned below:
SW1 East Harbour
SW2 Coal Harbour
and the last station for now
SW3 Exhibition Centre.
All stations will be overground.
SW1 would be@ the third level due to the space constraints.
Thats all for now.
Can anyone give me any feedback on this line.
Will be doing the RATIS today.
If this is gonna be another Harbourvale City Line, let's see if Nickgoh approves it. Other than that, Good Luck.
Hey Boylush, can I try the line? I will give feedback also.
Originally posted by Boylush:Okay. Maybe I will rename the line to South West Line as it does not make sense if I use the below stations
South West Line will be operating at these stations mentioned below:
SW1 East Harbour
SW2 Coal Harbour
and the last station for now
SW3 Exhibition Centre.
All stations will be overground.
SW1 would be@ the third level due to the space constraints.
Thats all for now.
Can anyone give me any feedback on this line.
Will be doing the RATIS today.
I guess I'll step in with my opinions again.
This idea is slightly better than the Resorts City Line. However, I have considered your suggestion and the line is not feasible because of the following reasons:
So in other words, I personally do not approve of this, and yes my words may be harsh here, but this is just my stand. You should contact me through email so that we can discuss more about this. Send me a personal message if you want my email address. :)
Well. Boylush, IF you want to do a route, Please Do Something OTHER Than A Harbourvale City Route!! Nickgoh already disapproved 2 Routes. Unless it suits all the requirements, etc. properly, then try again. (Best to keep on the NSX , my suggestion,as Nickgoh already disapproved twice. . Try it again and i think it MAY be disapproved...Why waste your time??)
Originally posted by Bngauw:Well. Boylush, IF you want to do a route, Please Do Something OTHER Than A Harbourvale City Route!! Nickgoh already disapproved 2 Routes. Unless it suits all the requirements, etc. properly, then try again. (Best to keep on the NSX , my suggestion,as Nickgoh already disapproved twice. . Try it again and i think it MAY be disapproved...Why waste your time??)
You can set it outside Harbourvale!
Originally posted by joeyfjj:You can set it outside Harbourvale!
Thanks.I will create another fictional country called Woodvale.
If other developers wants to develop in this fictional country , just email me @ boylush(a)ymail.com.
I will call this line South West Line .
Thanks for the suggestion.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Addon : This would be an LRT line