around 30 secs i guess.Originally posted by knightlll:Stay in the positon for how long ? As in per rep .
I think it could be longer. 30 seconds is way too short for any serious training.Originally posted by Simon Dean:around 30 secs i guess.
Not about the duration but density.Besides not everyone has the stability at first and this needs to be practised.Originally posted by eagle:I think it could be longer. 30 seconds is way too short for any serious training.
I think for pilates or yoga, you hold in the same pose for quite a long amount of time. It is similar to zhan zhuang in chinese martial arts, eg the horse riding stance, which you try to maintain for a long time.
actually I just tried.... 30 seconds is way too little of a challenge, that's why I would suggest at least a minute.Originally posted by Simon Dean:Not about the duration but density.Besides not everyone has the stability at first and this needs to be practised.
Many unconditioned people already have trouble stablising their core in the pushup position.Thats why i call for shorter times.Originally posted by eagle:actually I just tried.... 30 seconds is way too little of a challenge, that's why I would suggest at least a minute.
But I agree with you about density. So maybe we should suggest till you feel the "burn".
I was thinking perhaps there shouldn't be a timeline, but rather how they should feel. Unless of course, they cannot hold that position for even 20 seconds, which will be rather sad.Originally posted by Simon Dean:Many unconditioned people already have trouble stablising their core in the pushup position.Thats why i call for shorter times.
i can only do for 15*4Originally posted by eagle:I was thinking perhaps there shouldn't be a timeline, but rather how they should feel. Unless of course, they cannot hold that position for even 20 seconds, which will be rather sad.
You may be surprised at how hard 30s can be when you start doing it correctly. You probably won't be able to do the one with your elbow and feet in contact with the floor, but only the one with your elbows and knees instead, and even that would be tough for 30s.Originally posted by eagle:actually I just tried.... 30 seconds is way too little of a challenge, that's why I would suggest at least a minute.
But I agree with you about density. So maybe we should suggest till you feel the "burn".
There is none with elbows and knees I thinkOriginally posted by galapogos:You may be surprised at how hard 30s can be when you start doing it correctly. You probably won't be able to do the one with your elbow and feet in contact with the floor, but only the one with your elbows and knees instead, and even that would be tough for 30s.
yes there isOriginally posted by eagle:There is none with elbows and knees I think
I meant the above 2 pictures. Unless you mean there's a simplified versionOriginally posted by icyhell:yes there is
Hah, even worse. The front plank will be done wrongly by most people(even myself) who cannot maintain scapular positioning(winging), and for those with poor core strength, proper alignment of the body.Originally posted by eagle:There is none with elbows and knees I think
I have to admit, I only tried the front plank, and not the side plank yet. Will try that tonight. The front plank feels like when I do push ups, then hold myself in push up position close to the ground, yet not touching the ground.
I don't understand what is meant by scapular positioning. What I do is look sideways at a cupboard for a reflection, then try to hold the body as straight as possible. Try not to bend at all.Originally posted by galapogos:Hah, even worse. The front plank will be done wrongly by most people(even myself) who cannot maintain scapular positioning(winging), and for those with poor core strength, proper alignment of the body.
fyi, most people do pushups in a wrong too...many people have unstable scapulae that wing when in a pushup position. You can literally see them poking through the skin of their backs.
Scapular protrudes out.Originally posted by eagle:I don't understand what is meant by scapular positioning. What I do is look sideways at a cupboard for a reflection, then try to hold the body as straight as possible. Try not to bend at all.
yupOriginally posted by galapogos:You have a lot to learn then.
so if we have scapular instabilty, can it be corrected through using horizontal push/pull exercises? or is there another method?Originally posted by galapogos:Hah, even worse. The front plank will be done wrongly by most people(even myself) who cannot maintain scapular positioning(winging), and for those with poor core strength, proper alignment of the body.
fyi, most people do pushups in a wrong too...many people have unstable scapulae that wing when in a pushup position. You can literally see them poking through the skin of their backs.