(The following are extracts from a book I wrote)
Duration
The duration of the training session may be looked at in two ways. First being the total duration of the training session from the time the first warm-up exercise is performed through to the completion of the last cool-down exercise. The second is the duration of the sub-components of the training session. These may be categorized in two ways, general and specific.
Sub-Components of General Categorization:
1. Warm-up
2. Work period
3. Cool down
Sub-Components of Specific Categorization:
1. Self Myofascial Release
2. Integrated Flexibility Training
3. Self Mobilization Techniques
4. Isolated Neuromuscular Activation
5. Facilitated Neuromuscular Activation
6. Core Stabilization Training
7. Neuromuscular Stabilization Training
8. Reactive Neuromuscular Training
9. Integrated Strength Training
10. Integrated Flexibility Training
There a number of factors influence or are influenced by the duration of the training session and all of these should be taken into consideration when developing any programme.
1. Available Time
2. Metabolic and Neural stores
3. Mental Intensity
4. Hormonal Response
5. Multi-Day Training
6. Training Adaptations
7. Optimal Duration
8. Periodization of Duration
9. Recovery Ability
Available Time
The available time that the client has should be the first consideration when determining the duration of the training session however this is often overlooked.
There is no point in developing a programme that takes 75 minutes to complete when the client has only 45 minutes allocated as this would greatly reduce any chance of compliance on behalf of the client.
The available time that the client has to perform their training session should be qualified during the assessment while conducting the initial interview.
It is important to remember that just because a client has 2 hours to train each day does not necessarily mean that the training session should last 2 hours, in saying that there tends to be a common trend to the belief that the training session should be fully completed in 1 hour, this coming about mostly because of personal training sessions are charged by the hour.
Metabolic and Neural Stores
There is only x amount of resting stores of ATP-CP and neuro-transmitters. Going beyond the diminishment of these stores may result in a further shift from neural adaptations to metabolic adaptations which may result in a totally different training .
This is where some supplements may be of benefit in particular creatine monohydrate, which has shown to increase creatine phosphate stores.
Mental Intensity
Longer training durations will result in a decrease in mental intensity thus resulting in decreased performance. The psychological effect from this may last beyond the actual training session, affecting the recovery of the individual.
An increase in psychological stress levels can trigger the release of cortisol and other stress-related hormones. This causes a variety of physiological problems that can inhibit muscle tissue growth and repair, increase muscle tension, depress the inflammatory response, and depress the immune response, while also affect timing and neuromuscular coordination (Bloomfield 1996; Nordfors and Harvig 1997).
Hormonal Response
It has been shown that strength training increases anabolic hormones (growth hormone and testosterone). Increases in these hormones differ from male to female with females having only slight increases in testosterone, where both men and woman have a significant increase in growth hormone from the same resistance training session (Kraemer, 1991).
The above studies where conducted with an exercise programme consisting of three sets of eight exercises at a 10 RM with 1 minute rest between sets and exercises, giving a total training time of approximately 48 minutes (not allowing for warm-up period).
This increase in anabolic hormones may only be true up to a point. It has been theorized that there may be a decline in anabolic response as a result of an increase in catabolic hormones (cortisol, cortisone, etc.), that act inversely to the anabolic hormones. The time frame where these anabolic hormones may decline and the catabolic rise are theorized to be between 40-50 minutes.
Multi-Day Training
One way of possibly decreasing the potential catabolic response due to the duration of the training session without decreasing total daily training volume is through multi-day training. This refers to training more than once in a day, remembering it is far better to perform two 25-35 minute sessions (thatÂ’s work sets) than to attempt to perform one long 50-70 minute session.
A simular system has allegedly been used by the Soviet, Romanian, and Hungarian national weightlifting teams where they would perform several shorter in duration training sessions 20-40 minutes. One reason for this is to take advantage of the increased anabolic hormonal response. (Remember, they’re Olympic lifters, they may only perform one lift in each training session. They are also paid to train, eat, & sleep, not to mention what “supplements” may be added to the mix!)
A modem trend in strength coaching is towards decreased training time, which has been referred to as the “Bulgarianisation’ of weightlifting. This methodology of training has been endorsed by Soviet, Romanian, and Hungarian national weightlifting teams. It is often perceived as the “modern’ way of training developed by Bulgarian national weightlifting coach Ivan Abadjiev; however, it was already advocated as a superior form of training in the early l9SOs by the American lifter Charles Ross.
However you should consider that the use of multiple daily training workloads may be realistic only for full-time athletes whose recovery ability exceeds that of the average person who must also work. Of course, we must take into account that consumption of erogenic aids, namely androgenic-anabolic steroids and growth hormone is fairly common among some of these athletes and may shorten the time for adaptive processes to take place.
Training Adaptations
Short training sessions of 20-35 minutes may be more effective for neural training where longer sessions of 35-50 minutes may be more suited to metabolic adaptations (King, 2000).
These times seem very relatively short compared to what has generally been taught. However the rational for this is due to a number . Firstly, the rate of neural fatigue in relationship to training time.
Optimal Duration
The optimal duration of a training session should be somewhere between 20-50 minutes, depending the desired training effect; remembering that this does not include the other components of the workout such as the flexibility training and warm-up sets.
If more of a neural training effect is desired then aim for the lower end of the scale. When more of a metabolic effect is desired then aim for the upper ranges of the scale.
Periodization of Duration
As with all the training variables the duration can be manipulated to induce various responses. Generally longer workouts maybe more associated with a metabolic effect, whereas shorter workouts are more associated with neural adaptations.
However due to increased rest periods between sets with lower reps, higher load the duration of the training may not always be lowered despite the lower volume.
Recovery Ability
Individual recovery ability plays a role in determining the duration of the training session. If an individual is aiming for a metabolic effect but has poor recovery then duration should be kept towards the lower end of the scale (20-40 minutes).
To quote Charles Poliquin, “If your workout takes longer than one hour you are making friends, not training.”
It is important to allow enough time at the end of the workout for the warm-down as this can affect the recovery process or slow any corrective processes in place.