Not that they sounded like in the CD, but it was actually really the CD playing and the boys ad-libbing, not singing live.
Anyway, not that they are not able to sing live, coz I heard their singing in their Taiwan concert on ABCDEF4 and their vocal skills had improved vastly as compared to how they had performed in their debut album, especially Jerry. He amazed me with his improvement actually, considering he was so busy with his hectic schedule. Apparently, he was working for 34hours straight before attending the rehearsal 2 days before the actual concert. You can see he is really tired lor. Also, the day before the concert, the other 3 were given a break to rest their voices and bodies, but he still had to fly to Japan for a recording and rush back after that to prepare for the concert. But he is really hardworking, I must say. In fact, I believe the other 3 had actually commented before that he is the most hardworking of them all, but he always makes sure he is punctual and on time...don't you just admire him??

As for the other 3, Zaizai's delivery was not very well articulated (probably because of his Ilan accent) and a little muffled, especially when he sang Andy Lau's songs during the concert, but his voice is my fave. Vanness' voice is the public vote for being the best, so it speaks volumes about his singing prowess. Ken's voice which is more raw is more suited for singing rock-styled songs, like "Ai Bu Hui Yi Zhi Deng Ni".
[This message has been edited by Hajime (edited 05 November 2001).]